How the U.S. Government Had Sophisticated Design but Seemingly Lost it (And How to Get it Back!)

Dec 15, 2022

How the US Government Had Sophisticated Design, but Seemingly Lost It

Although often overlooked, Graphic Design is incredibly integral to government work. Federal government design specifically relies on past and modern-day successes of good design practices in America.

There was a point in history when Graphic Design in America was incredibly generic and uninspiring. That was until President Nixon implemented a Federal Design Program, highlighting the prominence of Graphic Design and making graphics conceptually stronger. For a decade, thoughtful Graphic Design was a national priority, but this development was lost over time.

Designing for the government presents several challenges, whether it's a proposal, whitepaper, website, etc. Among the challenges, adhering to government requirements and pre-conceived notions of design while still trying to achieve an aesthetically pleasing look and feel tops the list.

In this article, we will show how the past can help us create visually appealing and thoughtful government design in the future. To understand this, we will dive into three key areas:

  1. Moving from boring to bold
  2. Investigating good federal design
  3. Critiquing federal design

Understanding these key areas will help us implement visually bolder and more effective Graphic Design throughout our government work.

1 - From Boring to Bold in the 1970s

When President Nixon came into office, America saw a rise in consumerism led by the ascent of the television, the use of the photocopier, and the development of credit cards. While the economy was booming, there was no political or government focus on design or visuals until President Nixon changed that.

In 1969, Leonard Garment–a liberal advisor to Nixon and lifelong arts advocate–wrote a memo outlining why he thought “support for the arts is increasingly good politics.”

“In our country, cultural affairs represent an area of under-attention as compared to our technology. By providing dramatically increased support for cultural activities, you may gain increased respect from groups which have hitherto not been favorable to this administration.

For an amount of money minuscule in total budget terms, you can demonstrate your commitment to “reordering national priorities” and to emphasizing the quality of life in our society.

Federal design fell under the National Endowment of the Arts (NEA). As a result of Leonard Garment’s advice, Nixon doubled funding to the NEA. Through this program, President Nixon brought an influx of $40 million dollars to subsidized arts which resulted in major design revolutions for government agencies, including NASA, EPA, and the U.S. Postal Service. It was bold and transformative. The Federal Graphics Improvement Program brought private critiques into assemblies and conventions where designers reviewed several new “groovy” designs. Much of the design focused on how to cut down paper production, the use of color, and efficiency prioritization.

1 - NASA Graphic Standard ExampleImage Source: 19 Delightful Bits Of Vintage Graphic Design Inspiration — Smashing Magazine

There were projects like the National Park’s “Minifolders,” which reduced the size of brochures and clarified their formatting; the Internal Revenue Service’s graphics program, which helped recruit new employees and clarified the taxpaying process through redesigned forms and instructional booklets; and the U.S. Postal Service’s graphics standards manual and its Raymond Lowey-designed eagle emblem.

1 - IRS ExamplesImage Source: The Design necessity; a casebook of federally initiated projects in visual communications, interiors and industrial design, architecture, landscaped environment : Chermayeff, Ivan : Free Download, Borrow, and Streaming : Internet Archive 

Unfortunately, the successes of the Federal Graphics Improvement Program slowly fizzled out and ended in 1981. The need for graphic support from private agencies was no longer needed, some of which ceased due to lack of funding.

2 - Investigating Good Federal Design

The mission of the Federal Graphics Improvement Program from 1971 to 1981 was to save money and time while enhancing government communication. They fulfilled their mission through research and analysis to create visual systems tailored to agency-specific needs. When you think of federal Graphic Design today, it isn’t the most communicative or engaging visual, to say the least, and has clearly regressed over the years.

In truth, there are a lot of moving parts that need to be pieced together to achieve good design. Design should be engaging and persuasive. A prime example of engaging and persuasive federal design can be found in presidential campaigns. For instance, President Obama’s first presidential campaign in 2008 resonated emotionally with his audience and was highly persuasive. Another example is President George W. Bush’s second presidential campaign and the use of a cinematic ‘W.’ These examples have proven to be memorable and much higher profile than federal agency design although they are used in the short term.

2 - Presidential Campaign Examples

Image sources: Great Campaigns: Obama's 2008 Presidential Campaign and the History of Graphic Design: Presidential & Chanselorship Election Campaign Posters

There are examples of federal agencies that practice good design. The National Park Service offers a simple yet intuitive approach to its federal design, from its shield-like logo to the actual signage used to guide patrons walking through a  park. In contrast, the U.S. Army takes an obvious militaristic approach but is not overtly aggressive. They effectively and simply advertise to their audience with successful branding.

2 - National Park Service Examples

Image Source: The National Park Service Instagram

2 - US Army Example

Image Source: U.S. Army website

Good federal design isn’t limited to printed material and graphics, it also includes digital services. The websites of the U.S. Department of Education and Homeland Security boast a sea of information, all neatly organized. The takeaway from each of these examples is that they  focus on targeted audiences with intuitive, clear, and conceptual design. When your goal is unambiguous, it is easier to create effective designs. When you don’t have a strong concept, resulting design is unlikely to be as impactful or successful. 

3 - Why Critiquing Federal Design is Good

To have positive experiences in federal design, we must learn how to critique the work. What does this mean? Critique in this context is not necessarily art related. It starts with simply identifying user needs. Most of the examples we covered above achieved a lot with less. Designs can be reused without having to reinvent the wheel each time. We should look for accessibility in design, even if that means letting go of a more creative or bold design that we are attached to. If it is not useful or necessary to your users, do not include it.

several examples of proposal graphics

Sometimes design is determined based on needs. For example, the National Park Service’s road signs are something we see all the time. They are designed for easy communication and consistency. This is an example of a useful, practical design that trumps complexity. In government proposals, graphics should push the envelope of how design can create intent and purpose without having unnecessary elements. The graphics should be persuasive, clear, and compelling, in addition to being creative. Be sure to download our Initial Design Critique checklist to assist you in visualizing your graphics.

graphic design icons with download button

Conclusion

In conclusion, we should look to the past for inspirational design images and ideas like the examples above and allow them to influence how we create successful federal design today. While dated ideas of what proposal graphics and federal design may still exist, we can use the key areas discussed above as references to create good design. 

There are patterns to good design and a variety of useful resources, such as the KSI’s Initial Design Checklist above. If you are looking to outsource your graphics, the design team at KSI specializes in government proposals and marketing materials. Remember, the next time you design for the government, everything for you to succeed is right there, in the past and the present. 

graphic design icons with a button

Article Sources:

Keven Ramirez

Written by Keven Ramirez

Keven Ramirez is a Senior Graphic Designer at Key Solutions. He is an alumnus of the Maryland Institute College of Art and Design, graduating with a Bachelor of Fine Arts in Graphic Design. Keven loves conceptualizing and creating purpose in the design process to best fit KSI client needs and brand image. In his free time, Keven is an avid soccer player and enjoys collecting Hot Wheels.

Post a Comment

Lists by Topic

see all

Posts by Topic

see all